UPDATE: Here are direct links to the letters from the libraries mentioned below as well as others (via FCC Electronic Comment Filing System)
- Letter From Hartford Public Library
- Letter From Seattle Public Library
- Letter From New York Public Library
- Letter From Multnomah County Public Library (Portland, OR)
- Letter From King County Library System (WA)
- Letter From Pioneer Library System (OK)
- Letter From Memphis Public Library
- Letter From Rochester Public Library (NY)
- Letter From Urban Libraries Council ||| Letter 2
- Presentation to FCC Commissioner O’Rielly by Urban Libraries Council (June 20, 2014)
- Links to filings about ALA conversations with FCC posted on June 25th and June 26th.
These are just some of the more than 100 comments and communications filed with the FCC by organizations and individuals in recent weeks. You can review all of them here.
From The Washington Post:
Library directors from five cities, including Seattle, Memphis and Hartford, Conn., have sent letters to FCC chairman Tom Wheeler this week saying that they stand to be shortchanged if the commission moves forward with a plan to tie the money to the square footage of their facilities. Under the proposal, the FCC would give libraries a budget for WiFi funding at a rate of $1 per square foot — which some say isn’t nearly enough.
“WiFi costs are not merely a function of the square footage of a room with wireless connectivity,” wrote Matthew Poland, chief executive of the public library system in Hartford, Conn. “WiFi performance is a function of users.”
Poland argued that other libraries — such as those serving wealthy suburbanites — tend to be bigger. Not only would the proposed formula give more funding to suburban facilities, but those libraries would be taking in money that might be put to better use elsewhere. Inner-city libraries, Poland wrote, serve more users in a tighter space; their patrons tend to be less wealthy and disproportionately unemployed or under-employed. The upshot: It isn’t fair for large, rich libraries to get even more money when small, needy libraries might get less.
The article includes comments from ALA’s Marijke Visser.
Read the Complete Article
See Also: Modernizing E-Rate: Providing 21st Century Wi-Fi Networks For Schools and Libraries Across America (10 pages; PDF)
Published by the FCC on July 1, 2014. The full text report is also embedded below.